I quite like these new shoes from Crocs. They are called Prima (after the ballerina, one assumes). I am always on the hunt for nice-looking, non-leather shoes. I may have to find these and see if they fit. I'm pretty sure that normal Crocs would, but these are supposed to be less wide. They also come in a pretty turquoise shade: sea foam. I also like the green (celery), which looks a fair amount lighter on their website than it does in this picture.
The site also has some cute sandals. I like the ones above, as well as their Mary Janes.